• Twitter
  • LinkedIn
(503) 212-0687 | hello@cascadeinsights.com
Cascade Insights
  • Market Research Services
    • B2B Customer Experience Research
      • Buyer Personas
      • Buyer’s Journey Research
      • Key Buying Criteria Research
      • Jobs-To-Be-Done Research
      • User Personas
      • Customer Satisfaction Research
    • B2B Product/Service Research
      • Market Opportunity Research
      • Concept Testing
      • Go-To-Market Research
    • B2B Marketing Enablement Research
      • Data-Driven Marketing Research
      • Message Testing
      • Brand Research
      • Thought Leadership Services
      • Partner Enablement
    • B2B Sales Enablement Research
      • Competitive Landscape Analysis
      • Win-Loss Research
      • Churn Analysis
      • Channel Research
  • Marketing Services
    • Marketing Strategy
    • Messaging
    • Content Marketing
    • Sales Enablement
  • Insights and Perspectives
    • B2B Market Research Blog
    • B2B Marketing Blog
    • B2B Resources
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Our Clients
    • Client Testimonials
    • Careers
    • Ethics Policy
    • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Search
  • Menu Menu

B2B Book Review: Digesting “Disrupted”

May 25, 2016/in Blog Posts /by Sean Campbell
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share by Mail

Episode 126: B2B Book Review- “Disrupted”

http://traffic.libsyn.com/competitiveintel/B2B_Book_Review_-_Disrupted.mp3

This article is based on an episode of the B2B Market Research Podcast. The audio version is also available here.

It’s a different world from the era in which Apple, Microsoft, EMC, and other familiar titans came to prominence. Over the next 5-10 years, there will be a flood of people moving from the old guard tech companies to a new kind of company.

New guard companies are likely to be SaaS offerings focused on hot topics such as the Internet of Things, artificial intelligence, big data, and analytics. The new guard companies will include unicorns, technology start-ups valued at $1 billion or more. Unicorns such as Uber, Slack, Zenefits, and Docker will set the tone for the technology industry. Naturally, everyone is curious about what these new power players are like.

B2B market researchers are especially hungry to understand this new breed of potential clients.

Disrupted CoverIn this context, Dan Lyons’ book Disrupted: My Misadventure in the Start-Up Bubble is a must-read.

The book is a biting critique of the culture at HubSpot, content marketing, and the tech industry in general. Lyons has a sharp wit and comedic chops, but he also has the unfortunate tendency to over-generalize and over-judge.

Before I get into more detail, I’ll give a quick recap of the book. After losing his job at Newsweek, Lyons decided it was time to try something different. Hired as a marketer at HubSpot, Lyons felt like a fish out of water. The transition from journalist to marketer is a difficult one at best, but it’s not clear Lyons ever truly wanted to make it.

On the advice of a friend, Lyons decided to approach his new workplace with the mindset of an anthropologist. With this decision alone, Lyons shows that he was more interested in observation than assimilation. It’s safe to say that Lyons didn’t like what he saw at HubSpot.

Take, for instance, inbound marketing. Of course, inbound marketing is what HubSpot is known for. Lyons describes HubSpot’s approach like this:

“And even though we and our customers send out literally billions of email messages, we’re not trying to annoy people—in fact we are trying to help them. Sending one message after another, each time with a different subject line, is how we discover what someone wants. We’re learning about them. We’re listening to them.”

Lyons doesn’t buy this justification. He writes it off as “…pure Orwellian doublespeak. Night is day, black is white, bad is good.” I think Lyons’ take on content marketing is entertaining, but I don’t think he’s right.

Inbound marketing isn’t inherently bad. In fact, it can be valuable.

Inbound marketing isn’t inherently bad. In fact, it can be valuable. Customers do, at times, want to experience and engage with content that a vendor is producing. Sure, vendors that send out too many messages can cross the line into spam. But there is a degree of separation between inbound marketing and spam. The line between the two has a lot to do with how it’s managed, handled and sent.

It wasn’t just HubSpot’s philosophy that bothered Lyons, he found plenty to dislike in the company’s hierarchy as well. Ageism plagued his experience and he disliked how employees were motivated and managed. Lyons also witnessed what Guy Kawasaki called the “bozo explosion” where managers hire less capable people than themselves. Those less capable employees are later promoted to management, and, in turn, hire less capable people than themselves. Over time, the company becomes filled with less and less capable people.

Lyons also points out the rapid turnover at HubSpot. (Apparently, when people were fired from the company they were described as having “graduated.” In large technology companies, it’s not uncommon to find employees who have stayed with the company for 5, 10, 15, even 20 years. The typical tenures in recent start-ups are much shorter. I’m not convinced that the turnover is a bad thing, though. Only time will tell.

The funniest parts of the book are when Lyons is roasting HubSpot’s company culture. If Lyons’ descriptions are accurate, I’d agree that HubSpot has some work to do in that area.

From the descriptions in Disrupted, HubSpot sounds like a claustrophobic, hedonist playground. Employees are crammed together in a factory-like layout. There’s a candy wall. Lyons is told that “a group of bros meets in the lobby on the second floor to do push-ups together.” There’s a dry cleaning drop off. Legends of on-site debauchery make the rounds.

In a hilarious passage, Lyons recounts how one of the company leaders actually carries around a teddy bear as a stand-in for HubSpot customers.

In a hilarious passage, Lyons recounts how one of the company leaders actually carries around a teddy bear as a stand-in for HubSpot customers. As Lyons points out, it’s unclear how the bear could possibly lobby on behalf of the customers and whether the bear ever disagreed with the founders.

I think the teddy bear is indicative of the kooky things that happen when a company just talks to itself. Lyons is right to make us laugh about the teddy bear. However, when Lyons tries to generalize about the culture, I think he makes a few missteps.

Reading Disrupted, I got the impression that Lyons took his distaste for HubSpot and used it to diagnose start-up culture in general. I think his sample size was far too small to warrant such a sweeping view of the industry.

He reminisces about the bygone era when a team of technologists would build something wonderful and it would eventually find its way to the right customer.

At one point in the book, he makes a long running argument about how the technology industry used to be all about the technology. He reminisces about the bygone era when a team of technologists would build something wonderful and it would eventually find its way to the right customer. It’s almost as though he thought that if the product was innovative enough, it would just sell itself. That’s just not accurate.

As much as Steve Jobs loved innovating, at some point, he needed to just make a buck. It’s not as if Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, Larry Page and Sergey Brin were just innovating for the love of innovating in a vacuum where making money didn’t factor in at all. Products are generally intended to make a profit.

Business models have always been important. I’d say they’re equally as valuable as good technology because focusing on the technology alone doesn’t necessarily lead to a market or happy customers.

Overall, I think Lyons gives marketing a short shrift in Disrupted. As far as giving an inside look at a single company, it’s an excellent book. If you’re looking for a generalizable view of start-ups and unicorns, you’ll probably have to look somewhere else.

This podcast is brought to you by Cascade Insights. We specialize in market research and competitive intelligence for B2B technology companies. Our focus allows us to deliver detailed insights that generalist firms simply can’t match. Check out our podcast for more B2B Market Research episodes and articles.

Get in touch

"*" indicates required fields

Name
Cascade Insights will never share your information with third parties. View our privacy policy.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Bio
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Latest Posts
Sean Campbell

Sean Campbell

CEO
Sean Campbell is the CEO of Cascade Insights, a competitive intelligence and market research firm for B2B technology companies. A 20-year technology veteran, Sean oversees the health of the firm, drives the company’s thought leadership efforts and maintains relationships with key clients.
Sean Campbell

@sean_campbell

Sean Campbell
Sean Campbell

Latest posts by Sean Campbell (see all)

  • B2B Market Research: Exposing the Truth - August 23, 2022
  • B2B Focus Groups: Virtual for the Win - June 7, 2022
  • B2B Buyer’s Journey: Buyers and Marketers in the Blender - March 8, 2022
  • Bio
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Latest Posts
Isabel Gautschi

Isabel Gautschi

Director of Marketing
Isabel Gautschi

@Isa_belG

Isabel Gautschi
Isabel Gautschi

Latest posts by Isabel Gautschi (see all)

  • B2B Thought Leadership: How To Use Data Effectively - January 1, 2021
  • Nearly 80% of Business Activity Is Disrupted By Coronavirus - March 25, 2020
  • “I Have No Idea What Your Product Does”: A Cautionary Tale of Marketing Buzzwords - November 19, 2019
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share by Mail

GET IN TOUCH

hello@cascadeinsights.com

(503) 898-0004

WHAT WE DO

Market Research Services
Marketing Services
Subscribeto RSS Feed

Blog Categories

  • B2B Buyer Persona Research
  • B2B Channel Market Research
  • B2B Churn Analysis
  • B2B Competitive Landscape Analysis
  • B2B Customer Experience Research
  • B2B Customer Journey Mapping
  • B2B Go-To-Market Research
  • B2B Market Opportunity Research
  • B2B Market Research Blog
  • B2B Market Segmentation Research
  • B2B Marketing Blog
    • Uncategorized
  • B2B Messaging
  • B2B New Product Launch Research
  • B2B Thought Leadership
  • B2B Usability Testing
  • Brand Research
  • Concept Testing
  • Content Marketing
  • Customer Satisfaction Research
  • Data-Driven Marketing Research
  • Jobs-To-Be-Done
  • Key Buying Criteria
  • Marketing Enablement
  • Marketing Strategy
  • Message Testing Research
  • Partner Enablement
  • Product/Service Research
  • Sales Enablement Marketing
  • Sales Enablement Research
  • User Personas
  • Videos
  • Win/Loss Analysis

Written by

Sean Campbell
Sean Campbell
Isa Gautschi
Isabel Gautschi

RECENT POSTS

  1. The Smartest SaaS Questions on Quora
  2. Are You Shouting Into The Void? Market Research Lessons For Marketing
  3. A B2B Primer: VR
  4. People-Pleasing Is Not a Good Messaging Strategy

Connect With Us

503.212.0687

hello@cascadeinsights.com

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

B2B Market Research

  • Customer Experience Research
  • — Buyer Persona Research
  • — Buyer's Journey Research
  • — Key Buying Criteria Research
  • — Jobs-To-Be-Done Research
  • — User Personas
  • — Customer Satisfaction Research

  • B2B Product/Service Research
  • — Market Opportunity Research
  • — Concept Testing
  • — Go-To-Market Research

  • Marketing Enablement Research
  • — B2B Data-Driven Marketing Research
  • — Message Testing
  • — Brand Research
  • — Thought Leadership
  • — Partner Enablement

  • Sales Enablement Research
  • — Competitive Landscape Analysis
  • — Win Loss Analysis
  • — Churn Analysis
  • — Channel Research

B2B Marketing

  • — B2B Marketing Strategy
  • — B2B Messaging Services
  • — B2B Content Marketing
  • — B2B Sales Enablement

About Us

  • — Our Story
  • — Our Clients
  • — Client Testimonials
  • — Careers
  • — Ethics Policy
  • — Privacy Policy

Blogs

  • — B2B Market Research Blog
  • — B2B Marketing Blog
  • — Cascade Insights Blog
Cascade Insights is proud to be a member of the Inc. 5000.
101 Questions Stakeholders AskRead Like An Analyst: Dead Companies’ User Data, Bots & Reinventing...
Scroll to top